Review requests: check an alternative before you use it
Ask a teammate to check an alternative before it is used in the main design: they compare it in 3D, see the numbers that changed, pin comments on the exact spot, and approve or ask for changes. Use the alternative once it is approved.
A review request is a second pair of eyes for a physical part (a pull request, if you know software). You try an idea as an alternative, and before it is used in the main design a teammate looks at it in 3D and says "approved" or "change this first". With Pro terms on, the alternative is called a branch and using it is called a merge.
Request a review
- Work on an alternative and save a version of your changes (History → Try an alternative).
- In History, choose Request review on the Review requests card.
- Pick the alternative and where it should go (the main design by default), give it a title, and tick the teammates who should review it. They need the reviewer role or higher.
- Optional: Write it with AI drafts the description from the alternative's versions and its changes. It costs a small number of AI credits; edit the text as you like.
Reviewers get a notification that opens the review.
What reviewers see
The review page shows:
- Compare in 3D: the alternative next to the main design as it was when the alternative started, with removed material in red and added material in green;
- the changes in plain words and numbers, such as "Width 90 → 104 mm" or "Weight 41.4 g → 45.8 g (+11%)";
- the versions on the alternative (click one to look at it alone);
- the discussion: Pin a comment on the 3D view to point at a spot, @mention people, reply and resolve;
- the activity: every approval, change request and note.
Approve or ask for changes
Reviewers choose Approve or Request changes, with an optional note, or just Comment.
- An approval counts for the version it was given on. If someone saves a new version on the alternative, the review goes back to Open until it is approved again.
- A request for changes keeps the review in Changes requested until that reviewer approves.
- You cannot approve your own review.
Use this alternative
When the review is Approved, editors see Use this alternative. It works the same way as in History, including the preview and the pick-a-side list when the alternative and the main design changed the same thing. Both histories stay, joined by a new version, and the review is marked as used.
Statuses
| Status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Open | Waiting for reviewers |
| Approved | Has enough approvals on the latest version |
| Changes requested | A reviewer wants changes |
| Used (Merged, with Pro terms) | Its changes are in the main design |
| Closed | Closed without using the alternative; it can be reopened |
Required approvals (Enterprise)
Workspace admins on Enterprise can set how many approvals a review needs (1 to 5) from any review page. The rule applies to every open review in the workspace right away.
Try it
On an alternative with a change you are unsure about, choose Request review, tick a teammate and press Write it with AI for a first draft of the description. Then pin a comment on the spot you want them to look at first.
Did this help?
Keep reading
Ideas
Versions and alternatives
How History works in Solid Vibes: versions that save themselves at the right moments, Restore and Compare for any version, alternatives for trying ideas without risk, and releases that freeze what you sent to the factory.
Intermediate5 min readIdeas
3D comments, mentions and notifications
Pin a comment to the exact spot on the model, @mention a teammate, reply, resolve, and follow it all from the notification bell. Works in the editor, on review requests and through comment links.
Beginner4 min readAccount and billing
Plans and limits
What Free, Maker, Pro and Team include, yearly vs monthly prices, seats, and what happens when you reach a limit (spoiler: nothing is deleted or locked).
Beginner5 min read